סריקה בתהליך...
הניתוח עשוי לארוך 30–90 שניות
הידעת?
הסרטון אינו מכיל תוכן רפואי
חושבים שחלה טעות?
אם לדעתכם הסרטון אכן עוסק בטענות רפואיות או בריאותיות, הוסיפו הסבר קצר ושלחו בקשה לבדיקה מחדש.
הבקשה התקבלה! נבדוק את הסרטון ונחזור אליכם.
אירעה שגיאה בשליחת הבקשה. נסו שוב.
דו״ח מאומת
הסרטון מציג מידע מדויק ומגובה במחקרים מדעיים אמינים.
סיכום
הקליפ הציג טענות לגבי יעילותן של שיטות שטיפה ביתיות, כולל שימוש בסודה לשתייה, בהסרת חומרי הדברה מתוצרת חקלאית. המומחה אישר את הטענות הללו והדגיש כי היעילות תלויה בסוג הגידול ובאופי חומר ההדברה, תוך הבהרה שחומרים שחדרו לעומק הפרי אינם מוסרים בשטיפה. הראיות המדעיות תומכות בעמדת המומחה, שכן מחקרים מאשרים כי שטיפה במים זורמים או בסודה לשתייה אכן מפחיתה משמעותית את שאריות חומרי ההדברה החיצוניים, אך אינה מבטיחה הסרה מוחלטת של חומרים סיסטמיים שנספגו ברקמות הפרי.
דוח על סרטון תגובה
סרטון זה מציג קליפ של אדם המביע טענות רפואיות, ומומחה/מגיב שמתייחס אליהן. הציון מבוסס רק על טענות המומחה.
quiz טענות הקליפ ותגובת המומחה
"סודה לשתייה מוריד חומרי הדברה מאבטיח"
"סודה לשתייה יכולה להסיר עד 90% מחומרי הדברה"
המומחה מאשר שסודה לשתייה אכן יכולה להיות יעילה בהסרת שאריות חומרי הדברה, בהתייחס לטענה שהוצגה בקליפ.
מסקנת הבדיקה:
מחקרים מדעיים, כגון PMID 29067814 ו-PMID 30736280, מאשרים כי שימוש בסודה לשתייה (נתרן ביקרבונט) הוא שיטה יעילה להסרת שאריות חומרי הדברה מפירות וירקות, כאשר אחוזי ההסרה יכולים להגיע לטווחים גבוהים התואמים את הטענה. (🟩)
chevron_right מקורות מדעיים: (3)
-
link
Effectiveness of Commercial and Homemade Washing Agents in Removing Pesticide Residues on and in Apples.
Removal of pesticide residues from fresh produce is important to reduce pesticide exposure to humans. This study investigated the effectiveness of commercial and homemade washing agents in the removal of surface and internalized pesticide residues from apples. Surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) mapping and liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) methods were used to determine the effectiveness of different washing agents in removing pesticide residues. Surface pesticide residues were most effectively removed by sodium bicarbonate (baking soda, NaHCO…
PMID: 29067814
-
link
Comparison of Different Home/Commercial Washing Strategies for Ten Typical Pesticide Residue Removal Effects in Kumquat, Spinach and Cucumber.
Home processing can reduce pesticide residues in agricultural products, and the common forms of treatment include washing, peeling, blanching, and cooking. In this study, the removal effects of tap water, micron calcium solution, alkaline electrolyzed water (AlEW), ozone water, active oxygen, and sodium bicarbonate on 10 typical pesticide residues in kumquat, cucumber, and spinach were investigated. The residue magnitudes were determined by chromatography⁻tandem mass spectrometry (GC-MS/MS, LC-MS/MS), combined with the QuEChERS pretreatment method. The model tests showed that the results of soaking and greenhouse were close. The removal effects of pesticide residues in kumquat and cucumber washing by alkaline electrolyzed water with a high pH value, micron calcium, and active oxygen solution were better than other washing solutions. The sodium bicarbonate solution, ozone water, and active oxygen solution were more effective in reducing pesticide residues in spinach than others. Active oxygen solution showed a better removal efficiency for the 10 pesticides than other treatments because of its alkalinity and oxidizability. Among the ten pesticides, pyrethroid pesticides had a higher removal rate. Additionally, chlorpyrifos were the most difficult to remove. For the majority of pesticides, the pesticide residue magnitudes showed a gradual reduction when increasing the washing time. The results indicated that alkaline solutions were effective for the reduction of pesticide residues when the washing time was longer than 15 min.…
PMID: 30736280
-
link
Efficacy of Household and Commercial Washing Agents in Removing the Pesticide Thiabendazole Residues from Fruits.
Pesticide residues on fruits pose a global food safety concern, emphasizing the need for effective and practical removal strategies to ensure safe consumption. This study investigates the efficacy of household ingredients (corn starch, all-purpose flour, rice flour and baking soda) and four commercial fresh produce wash products in eliminating a model pesticide thiabendazole with and without a model non-ionic surfactant Alligare 90<sup>®</sup> from postharvest fruits. Surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS) was employed for the rapid, in situ quantification of residue removal on apple surfaces. Soaking in 2% corn starch followed by soaking in 5% baking was the most effective homemade strategy, removing 94.13% and 91.78% of thiabendazole with and without the surfactant. Among commercial washing agents, soaking in 2% Product 4 demonstrated the highest efficiency, removing 95.3% and 95.99% of thiabendazole with and without surfactant. These results suggested that the non-ionic surfactant did not affect removal efficiency. Both protocols were effective across various fruits (apples, grapes, lemons, strawberries), validated by liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) analyses. However, safety concerns regarding the composition of Product 4 highlighted the benefits of homemade strategies. Overall, this work offers practical guidelines for reducing pesticide residues on fruits and enhancing food.…
PMID: 39856984
person_check טענות נוספות של המומחה
טענות שהמומחה הביע שאינן קשורות ישירות לטענה ספציפית בקליפ
"חומרי הדברה שחדרו דרך הקליפה ונכנסו לפרי עצמו לא יוסרו בשטיפה"
מסקנת הבדיקה:
הספרות המדעית מבחינה בין שאריות חיצוניות (על פני השטח) לבין שאריות פנימיות (שחדרו לרקמת הפרי). שטיפה חיצונית יעילה בעיקר להסרת שאריות שעל פני השטח, בעוד שחומרי הדברה סיסטמיים שחדרו לעומק הפרי אינם מוסרים ביעילות באמצעי שטיפה ביתיים. (🟩)
chevron_right מקורות מדעיים: (3)
-
link
Effectiveness of Commercial and Homemade Washing Agents in Removing Pesticide Residues on and in Apples.
Removal of pesticide residues from fresh produce is important to reduce pesticide exposure to humans. This study investigated the effectiveness of commercial and homemade washing agents in the removal of surface and internalized pesticide residues from apples. Surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) mapping and liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) methods were used to determine the effectiveness of different washing agents in removing pesticide residues. Surface pesticide residues were most effectively removed by sodium bicarbonate (baking soda, NaHCO…
PMID: 29067814
-
link
Effects of processing and storage on pesticide residues in foods.
Pesticides are chemicals frequently used in agriculture to obtain maximum yield and improve product quality. Thousands of active ingredients and formulations of different pesticides are commercially available. Besides their advantages, a major disadvantage of pesticides is their residues, even though strict maximum residue limits have been set for each pesticide and permitted agricultural commodity. Permanence of pesticide residues on agricultural products depends on several factors such as the properties of pesticide, formulation, and applied concentration. Light, temperature, plant morphology, and plant growth factors are also effective in determining permanence. Degradation effects of the processing treatments rely on the dissolution of pesticides in the surrounding atmosphere, hydrolysis, microbial degradation, oxidation, penetration, and photo-degradation. Various steps applied during food processing, such as washing with water or other aqueous solutions, peeling, chopping, pickling, heat treatments, and processes such as drying, canning, fruit juice and concentrate production, malt, beer and wine production, oil production, and storage have certain effects on the presence of pesticide residues as well. Only washing with water can remove pesticide residue up to 100%, depending on the location of residue, residence time on food, water solubility of residue, washing temperature, and agents used to increase effectiveness. Besides washing, skin removal or peeling is one of the most effective treatments for residue removal, especially on non-systemic pesticides. During cooking, residues might be evaporated or hydrolyzed. Effects of storage temperature on reduction are related to volatilization, penetration, metabolism of pesticide, moisture content, and microbial growth, if any. In refrigerated or frozen storage, residues are stable or degrade slowly. Drying may increase the residue content because of the concentration, but in sun-drying reduction may occur because of photo-degradation. Clarification and filtration may eliminate residues retained in suspended particles. The degradation product, however, may be more toxic than the initial compound in some cases.…
PMID: 31858819
-
link
Selected food processing techniques as a factor for pesticide residue removal in apple fruit.
In this study, various food processing techniques, including high-temperature processes (pasteurization/sterilization and boiling), low-temperature processes (freezing), mechanical processing (peeling and juicing), and water-based processes (washing with tap water and ultrasonic washing) were used to identify the most effective way to remove contamination of 5 fungicides (cyprodinil, difenoconazole, fluopyram, tebuconazole, and fludioxonil). The most effective processes were juicing and freezing in the range between 63 and 100% and from 52 to almost 100%, respectively. Ultrasonic washing and boiling also significantly removed pesticide residues ranging from 79 to 84% and from 72 to 78%, respectively. The same trend was observed by peeling process where maximum reduction of 80% was achieved almost for all fungicides. Washing with tap water decreased the concentration levels in the range of 35-38%. This study demonstrated that the least effective and unpredictable method of decontamination of pesticides was sterilization and pasteurization, due to the large variation in pesticide levels during the process.…
PMID: 31776911
"שטיפה במים זורמים היא שיטה יעילה להסרת עד 70% מחומרי הדברה"
מסקנת הבדיקה:
מחקרים מצביעים על כך ששטיפה במים זורמים היא אמצעי בסיסי ויעיל להפחתת שאריות חומרי הדברה, כאשר אחוזי ההסרה משתנים בהתאם לסוג הגידול והחומר, אך מגיעים לעיתים קרובות לטווחים של עד 70% ואף יותר. (🟩)
chevron_right מקורות מדעיים: (3)
-
link
Effects of processing on carbendazim residue in Pleurotus ostreatus.
Samples of Pleurotus ostreatus were exposed to fungicide carbendazim to study the effect of processing on the residues. In most cases, processing operations led to a significant decrease in residue levels in the finished products, particularly through washing, drying, and cooking processes. The results indicated that rinsing under running tap water led to more than 70.30% loss in carbendazim residues. When dried under sunlight could remove more than 70.30% residues. There was a 63.90-97.14% reduction after steaming, with processing time extending, the removal rates increased especially for lower initial residue level samples. The residue was almost completely removed by frying combined with microwave heating. Furthermore, boiling the mushrooms reduced the residue in the mushroom and no carbendazim residues were determined in the broth.…
PMID: 27386113
-
link
Effects of household washing methods and post-ripening on the residue dissipation of the systemic fungicides mandestrobin and metconazole in Persimmons.
Studies evaluating the efficiencies of removing mandestrobin (MAND) and metconazole (MEZ) residues from persimmons using household washing methods are lacking. Therefore, in this study, the efficiencies of household washing processes in removing the systemic fungicides MAND and MEZ from persimmons (Diospyros kaki Thunb) and their dissipation characteristics during postharvest ripening were investigated. Following immersion, the initial residues were mainly distributed in the calyx (64.2-79.9%), followed by the peel (17.3-22.7%) and flesh (2.8-13.1%). Among the various washing methods, hand rubbing under running water yielded the highest MAND removal efficiency (78.9%) from the whole fruits, particularly from the peel (74.6%). Whereas MEZ removal was independent of the washing method (except for washing under running tap water; removal rate of 33.7%), with reductions of 51.9-58.8% within the whole fruits, baking soda was the most effective for the peel. Overall, hand rubbing under running tap water was an accessible, green approach. The residue levels exhibited no significant reductions over 21 d of ripening, and the respective biological half-lives of MAND and MEZ based on the amounts of the residues were 132.7 and 27.4 d, indicating extremely slow dissipation. These findings provide scientific guidance for effective washing practices and the improved assessment of pesticide exposure when using persimmons.…
PMID: 42310136
-
link
Strategies to Determine and Mitigate Pesticide Residues in Food.
This review provides a comprehensive overview of strategies to mitigate pesticide residues in food, examining both household and industrial processing techniques alongside the emerging role of Artificial Intelligence (AI). Simple household methods, such as washing, peeling, and thermal processing (e.g., boiling, frying), are effective. For instance, washing with running water achieves a reduction of up to 77% in residue for some vegetables. Additionally, processes like jam-making or frying can significantly reduce specific residues. Industrially, advanced methods such as ozonated water washing, ultrasonification, and cold plasma are employed for high efficiency while preserving food quality. Critically, AI is emerging as a powerful, indirect tool through predictive modelling, AI-assisted sorting/screening, and consumer guidance, enhancing precision agriculture and regulatory analytics. The review paper concludes that a combination of these diverse methods is essential for minimizing pesticide exposure and ensuring a safer food supply.…
PMID: 41515360
"יעילות הסרת חומרי הדברה תלויה בסוג הפרי או הירק ובסוג חומר ההדברה"
מסקנת הבדיקה:
יעילות ההסרה תלויה באופן מובהק במורפולוגיה של הפרי או הירק (למשל, שטח פנים, קליפה) ובתכונות הכימיות של חומר ההדברה (מסיסות, יכולת חדירה), כפי שעולה מכלל המחקרים בתחום. (🟩)
chevron_right מקורות מדעיים: (3)
-
link
Effects of processing and storage on pesticide residues in foods.
Pesticides are chemicals frequently used in agriculture to obtain maximum yield and improve product quality. Thousands of active ingredients and formulations of different pesticides are commercially available. Besides their advantages, a major disadvantage of pesticides is their residues, even though strict maximum residue limits have been set for each pesticide and permitted agricultural commodity. Permanence of pesticide residues on agricultural products depends on several factors such as the properties of pesticide, formulation, and applied concentration. Light, temperature, plant morphology, and plant growth factors are also effective in determining permanence. Degradation effects of the processing treatments rely on the dissolution of pesticides in the surrounding atmosphere, hydrolysis, microbial degradation, oxidation, penetration, and photo-degradation. Various steps applied during food processing, such as washing with water or other aqueous solutions, peeling, chopping, pickling, heat treatments, and processes such as drying, canning, fruit juice and concentrate production, malt, beer and wine production, oil production, and storage have certain effects on the presence of pesticide residues as well. Only washing with water can remove pesticide residue up to 100%, depending on the location of residue, residence time on food, water solubility of residue, washing temperature, and agents used to increase effectiveness. Besides washing, skin removal or peeling is one of the most effective treatments for residue removal, especially on non-systemic pesticides. During cooking, residues might be evaporated or hydrolyzed. Effects of storage temperature on reduction are related to volatilization, penetration, metabolism of pesticide, moisture content, and microbial growth, if any. In refrigerated or frozen storage, residues are stable or degrade slowly. Drying may increase the residue content because of the concentration, but in sun-drying reduction may occur because of photo-degradation. Clarification and filtration may eliminate residues retained in suspended particles. The degradation product, however, may be more toxic than the initial compound in some cases.…
PMID: 31858819
-
link
Selected food processing techniques as a factor for pesticide residue removal in apple fruit.
In this study, various food processing techniques, including high-temperature processes (pasteurization/sterilization and boiling), low-temperature processes (freezing), mechanical processing (peeling and juicing), and water-based processes (washing with tap water and ultrasonic washing) were used to identify the most effective way to remove contamination of 5 fungicides (cyprodinil, difenoconazole, fluopyram, tebuconazole, and fludioxonil). The most effective processes were juicing and freezing in the range between 63 and 100% and from 52 to almost 100%, respectively. Ultrasonic washing and boiling also significantly removed pesticide residues ranging from 79 to 84% and from 72 to 78%, respectively. The same trend was observed by peeling process where maximum reduction of 80% was achieved almost for all fungicides. Washing with tap water decreased the concentration levels in the range of 35-38%. This study demonstrated that the least effective and unpredictable method of decontamination of pesticides was sterilization and pasteurization, due to the large variation in pesticide levels during the process.…
PMID: 31776911
-
link
Strategies to Determine and Mitigate Pesticide Residues in Food.
This review provides a comprehensive overview of strategies to mitigate pesticide residues in food, examining both household and industrial processing techniques alongside the emerging role of Artificial Intelligence (AI). Simple household methods, such as washing, peeling, and thermal processing (e.g., boiling, frying), are effective. For instance, washing with running water achieves a reduction of up to 77% in residue for some vegetables. Additionally, processes like jam-making or frying can significantly reduce specific residues. Industrially, advanced methods such as ozonated water washing, ultrasonification, and cold plasma are employed for high efficiency while preserving food quality. Critically, AI is emerging as a powerful, indirect tool through predictive modelling, AI-assisted sorting/screening, and consumer guidance, enhancing precision agriculture and regulatory analytics. The review paper concludes that a combination of these diverse methods is essential for minimizing pesticide exposure and ensuring a safer food supply.…
PMID: 41515360
"בירקות עלים כמו תרד או חסה, שטיפה יכולה להסיר עד 77% מחומרי הדברה"
מסקנת הבדיקה:
מחקרים השוואתיים על ירקות עלים, כגון PMID 36141043, מאשרים כי שיטות שטיפה שונות יכולות להוביל להפחתה משמעותית של שאריות חומרי הדברה בטווחים המגיעים עד כ-77%. (🟩)
chevron_right מקורות מדעיים: (2)
-
link
Effectiveness of Different Washing Strategies on Pesticide Residue Removal: The First Comparative Study on Leafy Vegetables.
Leafy vegetables are used in various cuisines worldwide; however, as they cannot be peeled and their leaf surface area is large, the risk of retaining pesticide residues on these vegetables is relatively higher than on others. To our knowledge, this is the first comparative study to reveal the effect of removing pesticide residues from five artificially contaminated leafy vegetables (lettuce, perilla leaves, spinach, crown daisy, and ssamchoo (Brassica lee ssp. namai)) using different removal methods. The percent reduction range for each method was 43.7−77.0%, and the reduction range for the five leafy vegetables was 40.6−67.4%. Lettuce had the highest reduction (67.4 ± 7.3%), whereas ssamchoo had the lowest reduction (40.6 ± 12.9%). Spinach and crown daisy showed no significant difference in their reductions. Based on reduction by method, running water (77.0 ± 18.0%) and boiling (59.5 ± 31.2%) led to the highest reduction, whereas detergent (43.7 ± 14.5%) led to the lowest reduction. The reductions of chlorfenapyr, diniconazole, indoxacarb, fludioxonil, pyraclostrobin, and lufenuron in the leafy vegetables were lower with blanching and boiling than with other methods (p < 0.05). These results highlight the importance of thoroughly washing leafy vegetables to lower the intake of pesticide residues before cooking.…
PMID: 36141043
-
link
Strategies to Determine and Mitigate Pesticide Residues in Food.
This review provides a comprehensive overview of strategies to mitigate pesticide residues in food, examining both household and industrial processing techniques alongside the emerging role of Artificial Intelligence (AI). Simple household methods, such as washing, peeling, and thermal processing (e.g., boiling, frying), are effective. For instance, washing with running water achieves a reduction of up to 77% in residue for some vegetables. Additionally, processes like jam-making or frying can significantly reduce specific residues. Industrially, advanced methods such as ozonated water washing, ultrasonification, and cold plasma are employed for high efficiency while preserving food quality. Critically, AI is emerging as a powerful, indirect tool through predictive modelling, AI-assisted sorting/screening, and consumer guidance, enhancing precision agriculture and regulatory analytics. The review paper concludes that a combination of these diverse methods is essential for minimizing pesticide exposure and ensuring a safer food supply.…
PMID: 41515360
Matan Haber: Food Science
דירוג זה מבוסס על 6 דוחות אימות קודמים.
האם הדוח הזה היה מועיל לך?
מה היה פחות טוב? (רשות)
תודה על הפידבק!
עירעור על דוח זה
ספקו ראיות חדשות או הצביעו על אי דיוקים
נעדכן אותך על תוצאות הבדיקה
הוסיפו קישורים למחקרים או מקורות רפואיים מוכרים
העירעור נשלח בהצלחה!
המנוע המדעי שלנו יבדוק את הראיות שהגשתם. נעדכן אתכם באימייל עם התוצאות.
ניתוח מבוסס בינה מלאכותית
דוח זה נוצר באופן אוטומטי על ידי מערכת בינה מלאכותית ועשוי להכיל שגיאות, אי-דיוקים או מידע חלקי. הניתוח אינו מהווה ייעוץ רפואי, אבחנה או המלצה לטיפול, והוא אינו תחליף לדעתו של איש מקצוע רפואי מוסמך. יש להתייעץ עם רופא או מומחה מוסמך לפני קבלת כל החלטה רפואית. המידע מוצג לצרכי מידע כללי בלבד.
מידע זה מופק על ידי בינה מלאכותית ואינו מהווה תחליף לייעוץ רפואי מקצועי.